Welcome Guest Login or Signup
Live Chat LIVE CHAT  |  Live Chat INSTANT MESSENGER  |  BOOKMARK
 |  LINKS
No. 1 Free Classifieds and Pinoy Social Networking.

BLOGS   WRITE NEW BLOG   EDIT BLOGS  
 
BLOG BROWSER


 
RSS
WAR: Ugly!
Posted On 08/13/2008 02:19:26 by Edindustan
Lots of good and controversial stuff to talk about the Olympics; almost all ears are concentrated in China. However, allow me to skip China for this mid-week blog. Let me talk about the problem going on between Georgia and Russia, because one of my Russian friends asked me to join an online group about stopping genocide in Georgia.

An attempt to annihilate a people group in the planet is despicable. No one has the right to curtail the existence of anybody.

While I have been following the news, I got interested to know how the affected population look at the conflict.

Here are some words I gathered on BBC Online News (Aug. 13):

For many Russians, they were alleging that Georgians are trying to wipe out the Ossetians. Dmitry Petrov, an architectural administrator said, "The Georgian military has used...Grad mortar rockets...to destroy the city of Tskhinval and some Ossetian villages where there were many civilians."

For Georgians, they were blaming Russia and the Ossetian separatist for the conflict. Mikheil Sukhitashvili of Tbilisi, after realizing that the Russians are bombong outside South Ossetian said, "...We are just a small country and Russia is a superpower. Why are they bombin so far outside South Ossetia?...We(Georgian) do not have anything against the ordinary Ossetians. There are many of them in the capital...and they live peacefully with Georgians."

For Ossetians, they were glad that the Russians are helping them push the Georgian military away from their land. An Ossetian English professor said, "...We (Georgians and Ossetians) are a very different people." And they are hoping that Russia will continue to protect them.

Culling statements from all the people directly affected by the conflict tell us that Ossetians wants to have independence from Georgia (because they are different from them). Oftentimes, a conflict happens upon the initiation of a group dissatisfied of a status quo; hence, the group wants change. Since the news also said that most Ossetians are holding Russian passports (and not Georgian's), it could be interpreted again that they are not happy how the Georgian government is treating them. It therefore could be true that the Ossetian separatist asked the help of the Russians.

The problem with the action of the Russians is that it failed to respect the sovereignty of Georgia. Russia should have acted as a mediator between the Ossetian separatists and Georgian government, and not as an invader. Now, like any others, I believe Russian is more to be blamed for the escalating conflict. I just hope that the 5-Point Peace Plan that the Russian and the Georgian have agreed upon will be carried out by both government, because war to me is ugly, pure and simple.

THE UGLINESS OF WAR
(A Tercet)

The booming of heavy mortars
And the popping of bullets
Made everybody jumped over bars.

Running away from the hamlets
Scampering from obvious harm
From arms that left walls with pellets.

Bullets peppered mud walls in swarm
See e’en traces of shrapnel’s
Some when touched are still awfully warm.

Holes are even in tin barrels
Feel them, they are like Braille.
They’re so ugly like walnut kernels.

On paper, they look like a trail.
When read, it surely tells us:
War is ugly; it must not prevail.

Edmund Melig Industan (c) 2007

Note: Tercet or Terzet is a rhyming 3-line poetry form where the first and the third lines of the first stanza rhymes, the second line rhymes with the first and the third lines of the second stanza. The Ugliness of War is included in my upcoming book, 100 + 1 Poems on THE EXPERIMENTAL DASANG (Hey Poems)and 45 OTHER POETRY FORMS: An Anthology.

Tags: War Conflict Tercet Russia Georgia Ossetian



Bookmark:


Viewing 1 - 7 out of 7 Comments

From: Edindustan
08/14/2008 11:43:55
Definitely, my friend.  The Mindanado conflict, although it's  politically motivated, is so complex because religious ideology has been brought into the plate, too. (I assume that the idelogical interest is the reason why outsiders are supporting it.)


From: rushrash
08/14/2008 09:35:41

"Outside help". That my friend is really what we should be worried about.  Without us knowing it, we may lose ARMM to those "helping" to pursue this.

sigh. is really that all we could do?



From: Edindustan
08/13/2008 15:41:29

Thanks Princess and Rushrash.  German Military Theorist, Karl von Clausewitz, in his essay "On War" (1962) said, "The war of a community, of a whole nations, and particularly of civilised nations, always starts from a political condition, and is called forth by a political motive.  Also, war is not merely a political act, but also a real political instrument, a continuation of poliftical commerce, a carrying out of the same by other means." 

I am sure those who initiate conflict are using their intellect, however, it is sad that they resort to action that affects the innocents.  We have a Filipino saying similar to this, "Kung hindi makuha sa Santong dasalan, ay daanin sa Santong paspasan". But what's going on in the Balkan region, particularly the action of the Russians, is probably that the Russians still cannot let go of the thought that Georgia( and the other States) are not their subjects anymore.  Or if they already have let go of these independent States, they still have the idea of stirring conflict so that those dissatisfied (like the Ossetian separatist) would join them again. That's what ,I believe, von Clausewitz was trying to say.

And you're absolutely correct, Rushrash, to say that we, Filipinos, are 'greatly divided'.  Regionalism has been so strong, and regional pride take precedent to our national pride. Why do Hawaiian Filipinos prefer to be called Ilokanos than Filipinos. (Well, this has been changing already.) I remembered those days when I was taking my masters program in Baguio City in mid-70s.  My friend and I always received a shrug when we asked direction in our heavily-accented Tagalog. (I was born and raised in Mindanao) So, we ended up asking direction in English.  Shame.  Naging lutong hilaw na Americano tuloy kami.  Nasa Pinas pa pero pa-English-English na kahit don sa palengke, para lang makabili ng kamatis. hahaha.

The Conflict in Mindanao, albeit my province (Bukidnon) is not included with ARMM, is of great concern. Again, it's politically motivated.  And it is very possible that both sides,the govt. and the Muslim org., are using it as another instrument to carry out their political interest.  The problem is that outsiders are helping perpetuate the conflict.  Where's the money of the separatist coming from?  When I was still an exec. director of a NGO in Manila, there was a time when I have to make an emergency flight to Sultan Kudarat to meet with a "comdr." He threatened to harm our field workers who were assigned among the Cotabato Manobo tribe.   Since our org. does not support conflict as a means to an end, I have to convince this comdr. that the org. cannot give in to their demand.  Thank God, I was able to mention something ( call it the magic word) that made him changed his mind.  He ended up hugging and calling me 'brother'. He assured me that our field workers will be safe. Sad to know later in our conversation that, besides his education at FEU, he also got a warfare trng ( and support) outside the Philippines.  



From: rushrash
08/13/2008 13:57:46

Sad how we, as humanity has evolved?? or de-volved?? this way.

You mentioned sovereignity... What's your take on the conflict over the contested domain of the Moro's?

Sad how we, us Filipinos have been great.... greatly divided.

 

 

Anyway... Le'ts all stay positive and hope for a better future to our future children.

 

Thanks for this post. I haven't heard of this news. 



From: princess
08/13/2008 13:41:01

If we can evolve and think intelligently enough to be able to do all the great things that we do today, we can and must use our intellect to come up with better ideas than war to achieve Peace.



From: Edindustan
08/13/2008 13:34:10
Thank you, Woow.  I, too, is for peace. I loathe those who take advantage of the lowly.  As I was writing this, I was thinking of what's going on in Mindanao, especially what's happening in North Cotabato.  Thanks again.


From: woow
08/13/2008 12:48:44

I am a Pro PEACE activitist myself. Well done to you EDINDUTAN